Spuddy, my BMW M-Coupe. There are others like it but this is mine.
I wrote this as an homage to my car, but it's also a sale's pitch now I guess. It's currently for sale at Glenn Shelly Auto Consultants
Seems my cars all spend a little time at Simply Clean in Lafayette CO. Tyler, the owner applied a full hood PPF as well as a ceramic coat to preserve the paint's condition. My S52 powered M-Coupe is the slowest variant of the M-Coupe. It cost less than the faster versions, but It has other qualities of its own. So I spent less coin, comparatively, and still achieved total immortality and dominance at Colorado Cars and Coffee.
I always wanted a Dinan-badged car, probably due to something I saw or read in my youth. Glen Shelly found me an excellent example of a Dinan-badged M-Coupe locally with just 40,000 mi a couple years ago. It had a history of being an EAG car (Enthusiasts Auto Group, a prestigious broker). So, it was a cream puff but was not so perfect I couldn't enjoy the shit out of it.
So you kind of want one now too don't you? I understand. It's ugly, but you can't look away.
Why want the slower example of the M-Coupe? I didn’t, but I did rationalize it pretty well once I pulled the trigger. It was probably $15,000 less money, and much lower maintenance.
This US 1999-2000 M-Coupe has the S52 motor. If you’ve enjoyed any second generation E36 M3 then you know this 240hp motor is still very entertaining. While the power’s not mathematically impressive by today's standard the crescendo of its acceleration certainly intoxicating. Moreover, the reliability has come to be legendary.
I did need some data points to trash talk about faster S50 or S54 M-Coupes. So I started my Googling.
The S50 Powered cars were in Europe and the magazines worshiped them. Rated at 321hp they are quite impressive. A “Euro spec” car requires parts, knowledge and experience not common in the USA. So, unless you "know a guy" you can rationalize leaving these alone.
![]() |
Those individual runners on the S50 motors make power and complexity. Sexy shit, I know.. Like a supermodel, I can't afford a relationship with this one. |
S54 Powered cars were available 2001-2002. This is the model everyone talks about. It’s going to be hard to find something negative to say but I’ll try. These motors are more complex, more money, more rare, more powerful and simply too cool and too fast and fun.
Shit, I was supposed to be trash talking. I’ll try again.
I like the stares I get in the M-Coupe. More than I get in a 911, but less than a Shelby Cobra. |
The S54 M-Coupe is incredible but doesn’t scream like a raped ape as you’d expect. I know because I’ve raped an ape or two. That’s figuratively of course you perverts. Sad gearing and detuning done by BMW neutered them somewhat compared to the M3. Perhaps BMW did this to avoid hurting M3 sales. These motors are an amazing powerplant for sure but require diligence to avoid catastrophic engine failure (bearing failure). I really don't need more speed and less reliability, but my ego sometimes wishes I owned an S54 car.
Seriously, if you want a perfect car for your purposes, you have to be honest with yourself about how you plan on using it. Everyone says they want to drive to the track, beat the hell out of their car, then drive it home. But how many track days have you been on this year?
I'll be honest, I love fast cars and I hate the track. There I said it. I don't need to win any races, I don't enjoy hunting for rare European parts either. I do like shifting, I like redline acceleration, I like aggressively approaching on-ramps and I want to do it all going slow enough to keep out of prison. I have always felt the VW GTI, Miata and the S2000 were all almost cool cars. But I'm also quite shallow so an M-car bumps the coolness up just right for me.
Stuff I've done
I did get 3.46 LSD gears and that exceeded my expectations. Once installed I was quite satisfied with my acceleration even compared to the S54 cars I'd driven. I feel all variants of the M-Coupe were geared too high. But keep in mind I'm at a very high elevation in Colorado, so perhaps stock gearing feels fine at sea level.
A/C Overhaul. A lot the of the air conditioning system mine is new since it had a leak that was hard to find. This is not a common problem, but it isn’t cheap.Subframe enhancement. My subframe was perfect which is a big worry with these cars. I couldn’t stand the thought of finding a crack one day after driving down one too many cobblestone roads. So I had a the Randy Forbes reinforcement kit installed by Glen Shelly with a dual ear differential mount to stiffen things up.
Also this was an ideal time to install new bushings everywhere . Meaning front bushings, motor mounts and trans mounts in addition to subframe mounts. I figured, a 25 yr. old car should have rubber with the same level of wear everyplace. Otherwise, you can’t really call it the Ultimate Driving Machine anymore, can you?
Lugs are better than bolts. So I have replaced mine. If you've ever changed a tire, you'd understand. |
Radio mods are horrible value detractors to me. Buy a car with a stock radio and you won’t have to worry about the wiring massacre that may be behind the dash. Reversal of the hideousness for me was done with a new OEM wiring harness connector and a Blaupunkt unit that is a classic style, but blue tooth compatible.
The Condor shift knob is tall, but once you try it you'll like it too. Don't worry I still have the stock M-Shifter. Clutch pedal upgrade. These warp/bend because they are plastic and then look ugly. This really bothered me,
were fragile and break so I replaced them. Don't laugh or yours will break next.
Both of mine are 3-D printed replacements from 3DBimmer which are amazing. |
I was mortified my car had a Dinan badge, but no Dinan mufflers. So I rectified it ASAP
I suspect Stromung exhaust is the best value in exhaust. It is nice. I prefer the exorbitantly expensive Dinan exhaust, Aka Potato shooters. |
Cocomats, Just like all the classic German cars had in the 60's./ |
Stuff my car already had done that I appreciate
**My car has a Dinan Stage 3 tune with the various enhancements to make it happen. Thermostat, cold air intake, larger Dinan throttle body. What tune your car has matters more these days because some states are checking for aftermarket tuning and failing your inspection. |
Cooling system upgrades. This is not a surprise it was done, most BMW savvy folks address the water pump and/or radiator in the BMWs from this period of time.
Glove compartment sag repair. This is a common 90’s BMW problem. US models have steel reinforcement that adds weight leading to plastic fatigue. Many companies sell reinforcements which mine has had installed. As further insurance you should remove the sheet metal reinforcements in the glove box. That is how the European cars were sold.
Imagine my surprise, front and rear K40 radar alerts build into the gauge cluster. |
A previous owner sorted out the seat tracks for me. The side bolsters on this car were so good too. |
It has the proper a Dinan shifter, and the OEM lighted M-Shiftknob. The taller Condor brand shifter was a worthwhile upgrade that I use occasionally too. |
I liked the silly stickers, but if It's going to be sold, I figured it would be best to remove them. |
![]() |
A Porsche |
This is an awesome account of your stewardship of this well kept M Coupe. Love the details.
ReplyDelete